Arizona Asians banner
Living in Arizona

University of Maryland study links AI tutor access to lower grades and less engagement

Published on 11/16/2026
University of Maryland study links AI tutor access to lower grades and less engagement

University of Maryland study links AI tutor access to lower grades and less student engagement.

Photo: Arizona Asians / AI-generated image

A University of Maryland randomized study of 2,379 undergraduates found that access to a GPT-4o-based AI tutor was associated with lower final grades and weaker participation in online course activity. Researchers said the results varied by student group, with first-generation students appearing to experience larger setbacks.

A University of Maryland study has found that giving undergraduates access to a course-integrated AI tutor was associated with lower final grades and reduced participation in online learning activities. The findings matter because they challenge a common assumption that adding generative AI to coursework automatically improves student performance.

The randomized trial covered 2,379 undergraduate students and 30 instructors across multiple disciplines at the College Park campus during the fall 2025 semester. According to the university, the tool was a Virtual Study Assistant built into the learning management system, and students in the treatment group had access to a GPT-4o-based tutor grounded in course materials.

University researchers said the study is one of the largest randomized examinations of a chatbot-based academic support tool in higher education. The working paper reports that, among sections of the same course, access to the tutor reduced final grades by 0.37 standard deviations and learning management system participation by 0.90 standard deviations. The university’s education college said only about 15% of students offered the tool used it.

First-generation students saw larger estimated effects

The university said the negative effects were more pronounced for first-generation students. The working paper’s abstract says academic losses were greater in that group, while the university’s news release said the study also suggested the tool may have reduced office-hour attendance and time spent meeting with instructors and peers.

Jing Liu, an associate professor of education policy at Maryland and a lead author of the study, said students tended to use the assistant for answers rather than for tutoring-style learning. Jennifer King Rice, the university’s senior vice president and provost, said the results underscored the need for a human-centered approach and clearer guidance on how AI tools should be deployed in teaching.

The university said the Virtual Study Assistant remains available in 40 courses, but instructors have been informed of the findings and given guidance on best practices. Researchers cautioned that the results apply to the specific tool tested, not necessarily to every form of AI tutoring, and said the way universities design and supervise such tools will shape whether they help or hinder learning.

Topics

#highereducation#artificialintelligence#UniversityofMaryland#students#onlinelearning#academicperformance

Source: University of Maryland College of Education

View original source ↗